Wow, I really didn't think it would happen. As I commented on
Chuck's blog I really thought that Taylor, Mandisa, and Bucky deserved to be in the bottom three. Taylor and Mandisa had rough nights. On the other hand, they seem to have such a following that I really didn't think they would end up there after the vote.
Ryan pulled them out in three groups and each of the three was in a different group. Just like the NCAA - my bracket was blown.
Of course, they left us guessing as to which of the groups was truly the bottom three. I completely figured it was the group with Bucky, Katharine, and Ace and that the Taylor and Mandisa fangroups had kept them in the running. I thought it was a done deal that it would be Bucky saying goodbye.
I could hardly believe it when it was the Mandisa, Elliot, and Paris group. It did my heart good to see Paris there. She didn't deserve to be there for this week's performance, by any means, but she is just so damned annoying. It was good to see her get a little scare because she always seems to act as though she thinks she has won (at least from my perspective it seems like that).
America sent Mandisa packing. Her song choice was not stellar this week and even though she can really sing, she pretty much butchered the Shania Twain song. She would have been much better off with a Faith Hill or Trisha Yearwood or Martina McBride power ballad. I was really surprised by her choice and she just didn't pull it off.
With the exception of Bucky, those that are left can sing. Kellie and Chris are challenged because they are one dimensional singers and don't do well outside of their genre. It's going to be interesting right up until the end.